Apartments & Homes for Rent in New Haven, IN

RivoRent currently has 33 listings in New Haven, IN, with rents from $825 – $2,195 per month and 1 to 3 bedrooms. Browse photos, pricing and details below, then request a tour or apply online.

Listings: 33
Rent range: $825 – $2,195
Median rent: $1,675
Bedrooms: 1 – 3

See all 33 homes in New Haven Map view

24 of 33 homes in New Haven

Lowest rent first

Available$825
1 / 12
Tour Apply
931 Middle St unit 201
931 Middle St unit 201, New Haven, IN 46774
$825/month
1 Bed · 1 Bath · 364 Sqft
1 Bed1 Bath364 Sqft
Available$840
1 / 12
Tour Apply
2510 Sheridan Rd
2510 Sheridan Road, New Haven, IN 46803
$840/month
2 bd · 1 ba
2 bd1 ba
Available$840 – $1,920
1 / 27
Tour Apply
3234 Plum Tree Lane
3234 Plum Tree Lane, New Haven, IN 46774
$840 – $1,920/month
2 bd · 2 ba · 1624 sq ft
2 bd2 ba1624 sq ft
Available$840 – $1,920
1 / 24
Tour Apply
3209 W Bartlett Drive
3209 West Bartlett Drive, New Haven, IN 46774
$840 – $1,920/month
2 bd · 2 ba · 1464 sq ft
2 bd2 ba1464 sq ft
Available$840 – $1,920
1 / 25
Tour Apply
3232 Plum Tree Lane
3232 Plum Tree Lane, New Haven, IN 46774
$840 – $1,920/month
2 bd · 2 ba · 1900 sq ft
2 bd2 ba1900 sq ft
Available$920
Tour Apply
534 South Street
534 South Street, New Haven, IN 46774
$920/month
3 bd · 1 ba
3 bd1 ba
Available$920
Tour Apply
534 South St
534 South St, New Haven, IN 46774
$920/month
3 Beds · 1 Bath
3 Beds1 Bath
Available$1,260
1 / 13
Tour Apply
Gateway Apartments
9114 Parent Rd, New Haven, IN 46774
$1,260/month
1–3 Beds · 1–2 Baths · 900–1200 Sqft
1–3 Beds1–2 Baths900–1200 Sqft
Available$1,345
1 / 19
Tour Apply
920 Courtney Drive
920 Courtney Drive, New Haven, IN 46774
$1,345/month
3 bd · 2 ba · 1000 sq ft
3 bd2 ba1000 sq ft
Available$1,375
Tour Apply
9155-200 Starfire Circle S
9155-200 Starfire Circle S, New Haven, IN 46774
$1,375/month
1 bd · 1 ba · 687 sq ft
1 bd1 ba687 sq ft
Available$1,375
Tour Apply
9155-100 Starfire Circle S
9155-100 Starfire Circle S, New Haven, IN 46774
$1,375/month
1 bd · 1 ba · 687 sq ft
1 bd1 ba687 sq ft
Available$1,375
Tour Apply
9141-200 Starfire Circle S
9141-200 Starfire Circle S, New Haven, IN 46774
$1,375/month
1 bd · 1 ba · 687 sq ft
1 bd1 ba687 sq ft
Available$1,375
Tour Apply
9141-100 Starfire Circle S
9141-100 Starfire Circle S, New Haven, IN 46774
$1,375/month
1 bd · 1 ba · 687 sq ft
1 bd1 ba687 sq ft
Available$1,600
Tour Apply
9048 Starfire Circle N, Apt 101
9048 Starfire Circle N, Apt 101, New Haven, IN 46774
$1,600/month
2 bd · 1 ba · 1000 sq ft
2 bd1 ba1000 sq ft
Available$1,675
Tour Apply
9147-201 Starfire Circle S
9147-201 Starfire Circle S, New Haven, IN 46774
$1,675/month
2 bd · 2 ba · 997 sq ft
2 bd2 ba997 sq ft
Available$1,675
Tour Apply
9147-200 Starfire Circle S
9147-200 Starfire Circle S, New Haven, IN 46774
$1,675/month
2 bd · 2 ba · 997 sq ft
2 bd2 ba997 sq ft
Available$1,675
Tour Apply
9147-101 Starfire Circle S
9147-101 Starfire Circle S, New Haven, IN 46774
$1,675/month
2 bd · 2 ba · 997 sq ft
2 bd2 ba997 sq ft
Available$1,675
Tour Apply
9147-100 Starfire Circle S
9147-100 Starfire Circle S, New Haven, IN 46774
$1,675/month
2 bd · 2 ba · 997 sq ft
2 bd2 ba997 sq ft
Available$1,675
Tour Apply
9135-201 Starfire Circle S
9135-201 Starfire Circle S, New Haven, IN 46774
$1,675/month
2 bd · 2 ba · 997 sq ft
2 bd2 ba997 sq ft
Available$1,675
Tour Apply
9135-200 Starfire Circle S
9135-200 Starfire Circle S, New Haven, IN 46774
$1,675/month
2 bd · 2 ba · 997 sq ft
2 bd2 ba997 sq ft
Available$1,675
Tour Apply
9135-101 Starfire Circle S
9135-101 Starfire Circle S, New Haven, IN 46774
$1,675/month
2 bd · 2 ba · 997 sq ft
2 bd2 ba997 sq ft
Available$1,675
Tour Apply
9135-100 Starfire Circle S
9135-100 Starfire Circle S, New Haven, IN 46774
$1,675/month
2 bd · 2 ba · 997 sq ft
2 bd2 ba997 sq ft
Available$1,705
1 / 14
Tour Apply
3565 Canal Square Drive
3565 Canal Square Drive, New Haven, IN 46774
$1,705/month
3 bd · 2.5 ba · 1832 sq ft
3 bd2.5 ba1832 sq ft
Available$1,705
1 / 14
Tour Apply
3565 Canal Square Dr
3565 Canal Square Dr, New Haven, IN 46774
$1,705/month
3 Beds · 2.5 Baths · 1832 Sqft
3 Beds2.5 Baths1832 Sqft

See all 33 homes in New Haven

Renting in New Haven, IN: quick answers

How much does it cost to rent in New Haven, IN?: Rents on RivoRent for New Haven, IN currently range from $825 – $2,195 per month, with a median asking rent of $1,675 across 33 priced listings. Some homes list "contact for pricing" instead of a number.
What bedroom sizes are available in New Haven, IN?: Of the 33 New Haven, IN listings that state a bedroom count: 6 with 1-bedroom homes, 17 with 2-bedroom homes, 12 with 3+ bedrooms. A listing can appear in more than one group when it offers several floor plans.
How do I tour or apply for a home in New Haven, IN?: Open any listing to see photos and details, then use the Tour or Apply buttons to request a tour or start an online application. Section 8 housing vouchers are accepted — ask us in chat if you need help qualifying.

Rentals near New Haven

The closest places to New Haven with homes on RivoRent, nearest first.

More rentals in Indiana

All 296 cities in Indiana Browse rentals by state

24 of 33 homes in New Haven

931 Middle St unit 201

2510 Sheridan Rd

3234 Plum Tree Lane

3209 W Bartlett Drive

3232 Plum Tree Lane

534 South Street

534 South St

Gateway Apartments

920 Courtney Drive

9155-200 Starfire Circle S

9155-100 Starfire Circle S

9141-200 Starfire Circle S

9141-100 Starfire Circle S

9048 Starfire Circle N, Apt 101

9147-201 Starfire Circle S

9147-200 Starfire Circle S

9147-101 Starfire Circle S

9147-100 Starfire Circle S

9135-201 Starfire Circle S

9135-200 Starfire Circle S

9135-101 Starfire Circle S

9135-100 Starfire Circle S

3565 Canal Square Drive

3565 Canal Square Dr

Renting in New Haven, IN: quick answers

Rentals near New Haven

More rentals in Indiana

Questions? We're here to help.