Apartments & Homes for Rent in Fire Island, NY

RivoRent currently has 57 listings in Fire Island, NY, with rents from $2,250 – $22,500 per month and studios to 8 bedrooms. Browse photos, pricing and details below, then request a tour or apply online.

Listings
57
Rent range
$2,250 – $22,500
Median rent
$7,200
Bedrooms
Studio – 8
See all 57 homes in Fire Island Map view

24 of 57 homes in Fire Island

Lowest rent first

See all 57 homes in Fire Island

Renting in Fire Island, NY: quick answers

How much does it cost to rent in Fire Island, NY?
Rents on RivoRent for Fire Island, NY currently range from $2,250 – $22,500 per month, with a median asking rent of $7,200 across 57 priced listings. Some homes list "contact for pricing" instead of a number.
What bedroom sizes are available in Fire Island, NY?
Of the 57 Fire Island, NY listings that state a bedroom count: 1 with studios, 2 with 2-bedroom homes, 54 with 3+ bedrooms. A listing can appear in more than one group when it offers several floor plans.
How do I tour or apply for a home in Fire Island, NY?
Open any listing to see photos and details, then use the Tour or Apply buttons to request a tour or start an online application. Section 8 housing vouchers are accepted — ask us in chat if you need help qualifying.

Rentals near Fire Island

The closest places to Fire Island with homes on RivoRent, nearest first.

More rentals in New York

All 717 cities in New YorkBrowse rentals by state

Questions? We're here to help.

Chat with an agent, WhatsApp us, or message us on Facebook.

WhatsApp · instant reply, 24/7Chat on WhatsApp
Facebook MessengerChat on MessengerFollow us · new listings and updatesRivoRenton Facebook
Apply Now Contact page