1333 5th Avenue

📍 1333 5th Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706

📋 Property Overview

This home in Bay Shore, New York comes with 2 bd and 1 ba. It measures 624 sq ft. Monthly rent ranges $1,800-$4,410. Features in the home include stainless steel and recently renovated. The building offers parking and pet friendly. Pets are allowed. Parking is available: surface lot. The Walk Score here is 66, meaning some errands can be done on foot. Rent sits 42% below the area median ($3,100).

🚶 Getting Around

• Walk Score66/100

  Somewhat Walkable

📐 Floor Plan Details

• 2 Bed, 1.0 Bath2 bd · 1 ba · 624 sq ftNone available right now

🛡️ Renters Insurance — Estimated Cost

Based on what New York renters actually paid: NAIC industry data for 2023 (average HO-4 premium, 1,132,785 policy-years), adjusted to July 2026 with the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics tenants' insurance index. It is a market average, not a price for this building and not a price for you.

Your own price depends most on your credit-based insurance score, your claims history and which carrier you choose. In published Ohio figures the same coverage ranges from $127 a year at excellent credit to $933 at poor credit. We do not ask for any of that, so we cannot narrow this for you.

✅ Who Qualifies

Must have 3x the rent in total household income (before taxes)

🐾 Pets

Pets

Allowed

✨ Features & Details

• Pet Friendly
• Parking
• Recently renovated
• Stainless steel
• 2 bd
• 1 ba
• 624 sq ft

📊 Property Facts

Walk Score

66 · Somewhat Walkable

🚗 Parking

• Surface lot

🏡 Floor Plans