3 Shelter Island Avenue

📍 3 Shelter Island Avenue, North Haven, NY 11963

📋 Property Overview

This home in North Haven, New York comes with 6 bd / 5 ba. Monthly rent is $4,995. Features in the home include fireplace, recently renovated and patio / balcony. The building offers fire pit, basketball court and pool. Pets are allowed. Leases run 12 months. Availability: Available now. With a Walk Score of 1, most errands need a car. Rent is well below the area median of $15,000.

🚶 Getting Around

• Walk Score1/100

  Car-Dependent

💵 Costs & Lease

Lease length

12 months

Units available

1 unit

Amounts are as published by the source and may change. Confirm before applying.

📐 Floor Plan Details

• 6 Bed, 5.0 Bath6 bd · 5 ba$4,9951 unit available

🧾 Move-in Costs & Lease

Lease length

12 months

Available

Available now

Application fee

$60 per applicant, paid to RivoRent

Property amounts are as published by the source and may change. Confirm before applying. The application fee is RivoRent's own and is the same on every listing.

🛡️ Renters Insurance — Estimated Cost

Based on what New York renters actually paid: NAIC industry data for 2023 (average HO-4 premium, 1,132,785 policy-years), adjusted to July 2026 with the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics tenants' insurance index. It is a market average, not a price for this building and not a price for you.

Your own price depends most on your credit-based insurance score, your claims history and which carrier you choose. In published Ohio figures the same coverage ranges from $127 a year at excellent credit to $933 at poor credit. We do not ask for any of that, so we cannot narrow this for you.

✅ Who Qualifies

Must have 3x the rent in total household income (before taxes)

🐾 Pets

Pets

Allowed

✨ Features & Details

• Pet Friendly
• Patio / balcony
• Recently renovated
• Pool
• Basketball court
• Fire pit
• Fireplace
• 0 sq ft

📊 Property Facts

Walk Score

1 · Car-Dependent

🚗 Parking

No parking on site

🎓 Nearby Schools

• Sag Harbor Elementary School · PK-54/10 · 2.5 mi
• Pierson Middle High School · 6-128/10 · 2.6 mi
• Shelter Island School · PK-124/10 · 3.0 mi
• Greenport Elementary School · PK-62/10 · 5.9 mi
• Greenport High School · 7-122/10 · 5.9 mi
• Bridgehampton School · PK-125/10 · 6.3 mi
• Southold Junior Senior High School · 7-125/10 · 6.5 mi
• Southold Elementary School · K-63/10 · 6.5 mi
• East Hampton High School · 9-125/10 · 7.0 mi
• John M Marshall Elementary School · K-57/10 · 7.7 mi

🏡 Floor Plans