Mid Island Apartments

📍 35 Penataquit Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706

📋 Property Overview

Mid Island Apartments is a home in Bay Shore, New York with Studio - 2 bd, 1 ba. The floor plan measures 400 sq ft. Monthly rent ranges $1,885-$2,795. Inside, the home includes air conditioning, range, smoke-free units and dishwasher. Shared amenities include pet friendly, online portal, coffee bar and cats allowed. Pets are allowed (cats and dogs), with pet rent of $50. Leases run 12 months. Availability: Available now. With a Walk Score of 62, some errands can be done on foot. Rent sits 39% below the area median ($3,100).

🚶 Getting Around

• Walk Score62/100

  Somewhat Walkable

💵 Costs & Lease

Lease length

12 months

Units available

18 units

Amounts are as published by the source and may change. Confirm before applying.

📐 Floor Plan Details

• S1Studio · 1 ba · 400 sq ft$1,8853 units available
• A11 bd · 1 ba · 665 sq ft$1,9306 units available
• A21 bd · 1 ba · 705 sq ft$2,2902 units available
• B12 bd · 1 ba · 820 sq ft$2,4205 units available
• B52 bd · 1 ba · 915 sq ft$2,7951 unit available
• B42 bd · 1.5 ba · 875 sq ftNone available right now
• B22 bd · 1 ba · 840 sq ft$2,3251 unit available

🧾 Move-in Costs & Lease

Lease length

12 months

Available

Available now

Application fee

$60 per applicant, paid to RivoRent

Property amounts are as published by the source and may change. Confirm before applying. The application fee is RivoRent's own and is the same on every listing.

🛡️ Renters Insurance — Estimated Cost

Based on what New York renters actually paid: NAIC industry data for 2023 (average HO-4 premium, 1,132,785 policy-years), adjusted to July 2026 with the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics tenants' insurance index. It is a market average, not a price for this building and not a price for you.

Your own price depends most on your credit-based insurance score, your claims history and which carrier you choose. In published Ohio figures the same coverage ranges from $127 a year at excellent credit to $933 at poor credit. We do not ask for any of that, so we cannot narrow this for you.

🐾 Pets

Pets

Allowed

Types

Cats, Dogs

Pet rent

$50

One-time pet fee

$250

Limit

2 pets

Restrictions

Breed Restrictions Apply.

✨ Features & Details

• Pet Friendly
• On-site laundry
• Hardwood floors
• Dishwasher
• Parking
• Walk in closets
• Air conditioning
• Range
• Ceiling fan
• Smoke-free units
• Coffee bar
• Courtyard
• Playground
• Cats allowed
• Dogs allowed
• Accessible
• E-payments
• Online portal
• 400 sq ft
• 665 sq ft
• 705 sq ft
• 820 sq ft
• 915 sq ft
• 840 sq ft

📊 Property Facts

Walk Score

62 · Somewhat Walkable

🎓 Nearby Schools

• Bay Shore Senior High School · 9-125/10 · 0.8 mi
• Islip Middle School · 6-86/10 · 0.8 mi
• Islip High School · 9-127/10 · 1.0 mi
• Bay Shore Middle School · 6-86/10 · 1.1 mi
• Commack Road Elementary School · 2-52/10 · 1.4 mi
• Maud S Sherwood Elementary School · 2-52/10 · 1.5 mi
• Gardiner Manor School · 3-52/10 · 2.0 mi
• Loretta Park Elementary School · 1-54/10 · 2.2 mi
• Laurel Park Elementary School · 1-53/10 · 2.3 mi
• South Country School · 3-55/10 · 2.4 mi

🏡 Floor Plans

0631E

400 sq ft · 12 mo

Available now

$1,885

0532B

400 sq ft · 12 mo

Oct 1, 2026

$1,895

0551C

400 sq ft · 12 mo

Available now

$1,955

0211A

665 sq ft · 12 mo

Available now

$1,930

0231D

665 sq ft · 12 mo

Oct 1, 2026

$1,930

0112D

665 sq ft · 12 mo

Available now

$2,245